Accidentally Recorded Our Realest Poly Conversation

The Guest Ghosted. The Mics Were Hot. And Somehow This Became One of Our Best Episodes.

Let us set the scene for you. It's a normal recording day at Beyond Monogamy HQ (aka the spare bedroom that smells faintly of candles and questionable decisions). Adam and Pris are all mic'd up, coffee in hand, waiting on a guest who — spoiler alert — was not coming. At all. No call, no text, no carrier pigeon. Just vibes and silence.

Now, any reasonable podcasting couple would have turned off the equipment, poured a drink, and called it a day. But here's the thing about Adam and Pris: they were already talking. Already recording. And the conversation that happened in that waiting room silence? Reader, it became a Quickie.

The Poly Bomb Heard 'Round the Lifestyle

Out of absolutely nowhere, Pris — the woman who once described her approach to new people as "extensive background check with neighborhood interviews" — casually mentioned she'd be open to trying polyamory again.

Adam's face: 🫠

To be fair, they did try poly before — back in what Adam lovingly refers to as their "we had no idea what we were doing and it showed" era. They were vetting vanillas, chasing the poster-perfect image of what polyamory "should" look like, and pushing each other into experiences before either of them was actually ready. Classic early-lifestyle energy.

But this time feels different. They've hosted over a hundred conversations on Beyond Monogamy. They've talked to poly experts, relationship anarchists, kitchen-table polycules, and everyone in between. They know what they didn't know then. And maybe — just maybe — they're ready to do it right.

Pris's Stipulations: A Comprehensive List

Now, Pris being Pris, she didn't just say "yeah sure let's date people." She arrived to this conversation with a full list of requirements that honestly sounds less like dating criteria and more like a federal security clearance application. Let's review:

• ✅ Must be lifestyle-experienced (no vanillas, period, end of list)
• ✅ Married with kids, similar age, people they can actually relate to
• ✅ Solid as a couple — not trying to use a new relationship to patch a leaking one
• ✅ No hard liquor (White Claw acceptable, hard liquor is a dealbreaker)
• ✅ 420-friendly — shrooms optional but possible
• ✅ ADHD, ideally (Pris needs her people)
• ✅ Must be in the group chat. ALL of them. No secret side DMs
• ✅ No infidelity history, no abusiveness, no entitlement
• ❌ No clinginess. We like our time. We are not your entire social life.
• ❌ Pris is "not a side hoe." She is a flower. She is to be shown.

Adam, staring into the middle distance: "So basically a unicorn couple."
Pris: "We are ready."

On Jealousy, Compersion, and the Dutch Bros Incident

This episode gets real real when Pris admits she wants Adam to sometimes stop her from doing things — not because she doesn't want to do them, but because it would make her feel loved. Adam, being the compersion-positive, fully-supportive partner he is, short-circuited completely.

"You want me to prove my love by not supporting you?" he asked, with the energy of a man watching his whole worldview dissolve in real time.

Yes. That is what she wants. Specifically regarding Dutch Bros.

This is ethical non-monogamy, baby — messy, honest, hormone-fueled, and utterly human. No scripts. No performance. Just two people who have been doing this together for 15 years, still figuring it out in real time.

What They Actually Learned From Doing Poly Wrong

One of the most valuable parts of this conversation is Adam's honest reflection on how he approached polyamory the first time. He was chasing the idea of what poly should look like rather than building something real. He was vetting poorly. He was letting Pris's discomfort get steamrolled by his excitement. And he was pushing her to pursue connections of her own — not because he wanted that for her, but because it made him feel less guilty about pursuing his own.

That's a level of self-awareness that only comes from 15 years in the lifestyle, 18 months of a podcast, and a no-show guest who accidentally created space for the most honest conversation they've had in a while.

The Verdict

Are Adam and Pris going poly again? Maybe. Probably not tomorrow. Definitely not without a 6–12 month vetting period, a group chat, and someone who can pass Pris's vibes test. But the door is open. And that's kind of beautiful.

Subscribe, follow, and catch every episode of Beyond Monogamy with Adam & Pris at beyond-monogamy.com. We're also on Full Swap Radio every Thursday at 2PM & 7PM Central at fullswapradio.com.

Upcoming Events

• Beyond Monogamy Live @ Club Eden San Antonio — June 20
• Naughty N'awlins — July 8–12, New Orleans
• Krazy Winter Nights – Kansas City — Feb 19–21, 2027 | Use code BEYOMONO at krazykasbh.com

This Episode Is Brought to You by FirmTech

Speaking of performing at your best — meet FirmTech, the award-winning, doctor-designed wearable ring that tracks your sexual health data and heightens sensitivity. Whether you're navigating a new relationship or just want to know your numbers, FirmTech's TechRing syncs with an app to give you real insights about your sexual health — the kind you can actually share with your healthcare provider. Use code BEYOMONO at myfirmtech.com to save.