🎉 Our Facebook Communities are LIVE! Come find your people →
Beyond Monogamy with Adam & Pris

What If Non-Monogamy Was Normal? Catholic Guilt & Our Alternate Lives | Swinger Podcast

What if non-monogamy had always been normal? Would we have married, cheated, had kids, or even found each other? A listener voicemail made Adam & Pris answer.

On this episode of Beyond Monogamy, the swinger and ethical non-monogamy (ENM) podcast, we imagine the versions of ourselves that never got the chance to exist. We both grew up Catholic in Mexican-American households with a strict script for how a good man and a good woman should live. We talk about Pris's childhood crushes on girls and staying closeted, Adam's "girl-crazy" shame, whether there'd be less cheating if open relationships were accepted, wanting "the one," having a primary, Catholic guilt, Adam's years in the seminary, and machismo in the lifestyle. Then we finish with an alternate-timeline lightning round. It's one of our most personal episodes ever.

IN THIS EPISODE:
- The listener voicemail that started it all
- Growing up bi in a strict Mexican Catholic household
- Adam's "girl-crazy" shame and the aunt with a boyfriend
- Would cheating disappear if non-monogamy were normal?
- Wanting "the one," primaries, and why poly didn't work for us
- Could either of us go back to monogamy?
- Catholic guilt and why Adam left the seminary
- Machismo, toxic masculinity, and Latinx couples in the lifestyle
- Lightning round: at 18, who are we dating, and do we still find each other?

THANKS TO OUR SPONSOR:

SDC: The largest online community for open-minded adults. Make a profile and go explore. Sign up with code 38236.
https://www.sdc.com/?ref=38236

COME HANG OUT WITH US:

Krazy Winter Nights, Kansas City: February 19–21, 2027. Use code BEYOMONO for a discount.
https://krazykasbh.com

Full Swap Radio: Streaming every Thursday at 2:00 PM and 7:00 PM Central.
https://fullswapradio.com

Tell us your other timeline in our 100% anonymous confessional, and check out merch, past episodes, and our blog:
https://beyond-monogamy.com

Tell us in the comments: what would YOUR life look like if non-monogamy had always been normal?

If this one hit home, SUBSCRIBE, turn on notifications, and share it with someone who grew up with rules that didn't fit.

#EthicalNonMonogamy #SwingerLifestyle #ENM #OpenRelationship #SwingerPodcast #CatholicGuilt #BeyondMonogamy

Send Us A Voicemail