Do Swingers Get Nervous? Confidence & Anxiety in the Lifestyle

Fifteen years in the swinger lifestyle. Hundreds of meets, greets, parties, and playdates. Surely by now the butterflies are gone, right? RIGHT?

Well. About that.

In this quickie episode of Beyond Monogamy, Adam & Pris tackle a question they get asked constantly by people new to ethical non-monogamy: does the nervousness ever go away? And the answer, delivered with all the marital side-eye you've come to expect from this swinger podcast, is: it depends on which one of you we're talking about.

Tale of Two Nervous Systems

Pris used to get nervous. Past tense. Once upon a time she'd worry when somebody new came over — what if they don't like the way I look? Then somewhere around the COVID era, a switch flipped, and she emerged from lockdown a fully operational confidence machine. Her exact philosophy, quote: "I am who I am. I don't care if people like me or not. Because I probably don't like them." Ladies and gentlemen, growth.

Adam, meanwhile... still gets nervous. After 15 years. Even with friends. Even when the playdate is planned, scheduled, and confirmed like a dentist appointment. A friend came over recently for a little threesome action and Adam was nervous. Pris? Cool as the other side of the pillow. Marriage is about balance, folks.

The Hotline Between a Man's Brain and His... Confidence

Here's the part the brochures don't tell you about open relationships: for guys, the brain and the manhood are in constant communication. They talk. They text. They gossip. And the moment a nervous man tells himself, "Okay dude, you gotta get hard NOW" — congratulations, you have guaranteed the exact opposite outcome. As Adam puts it, if he has to give himself a pep talk to sack up, he might as well call it a day. Women get to hide their nerves. Men's nerves hold a press conference.

People-Pleasing Anonymous, Party of One

A big chunk of this episode is really about wanting to be liked. Adam has wanted everybody to like him since elementary school and still short-circuits when someone doesn't ("We were FINE. What HAPPENED?"). Pris, on the other hand, figures if someone doesn't like her, it's because she didn't like them first and they felt the energy. Checkmate.

This spirals into a genuinely great married-couple moment where Adam suggests Pris could maybe shrink the ego a smidge, Pris demands to know the difference between confident and egotistical, and an actual definition gets read out loud on air. Verdict: she's confident, not egotistical. The court accepts, reluctantly.

But underneath the banter there's a real arc here. Pris spent most of her life as a people-pleaser and a pushover, never thought she was pretty, never thought she was smart — and had to deliberately build the self-love she now weaponizes so effectively. And longtime listeners know 2025 kicked off the Year of Confident Adam. It's a work in progress. The scaffolding is still up. But progress is progress.

Actual Advice That Actually Works

Buried in the laughs is some of the most practical guidance this non-monogamy podcast has ever dropped for nervous guys in the lifestyle. Adam's system: tell her ONCE that you find her attractive and you're interested. Then never say it again. Just be her friend. No pressure, no repeat performances, no throwing yourself at every woman who walks through the club door. The interest is on file. She knows where to find it. And while she's getting to know the real you, she gets to arrive at her own conclusions on her own schedule. "For all you guys out there who struggle — I'm telling you, this shit works." Even Pris co-signs, which, as you now know, she does not do out of politeness.

The flip side: hypersexual confidence — the "bah, I want this" approach — flies with almost nobody. Confidence in yourself as a person? Sexy. Confidence that you are God's gift delivered with a wink and a nipple rub? Blocked.

Spicy Pic Etiquette: A Public Service Announcement

Speaking of blocked: the conversation takes a detour into the great spicy-pic debate, and Pris lays down the law. Does she enjoy them? Actually, yes — from people she's already talking to, who asked first. Randoms sliding into DMs unannounced? Blocked. Immediately. Well-endowed randoms? Still blocked. There is no exception clause, gentlemen. Ask. First.

And then there's the segment about "tribute" videos involving tablets that we simply cannot summarize in a family-adjacent blog post, except to note that Adam's engineering-minded alternative involves a transparency sheet, and Pris's response was two words: "Shoot your web." You'll just have to listen.

The Least Suave Moment in Exhibitionism History

Pris closes with the confidence masterclass: stretch marks, mom tummy, zero you-know-whats given, walking through the club in lingerie like a runway. Adam closes with the confession that after their exhibitionism moments, he yanks his underwear back on so fast that his feet get tangled and he stumbles — drawing far more attention than if he'd just taken his time. There is, he concedes, no suave way to do it. He's right. There isn't. We've all been there.

So... Does the Nervousness Ever Go Away?

Yes. To an extent. It depends on you, your mindset, and whether you've done the unsexy inner work of actually liking yourself. Because in the swinger community, confidence is the sexiest thing you can wear — even if what's underneath has stretch marks, anxiety, or a 15-year case of the butterflies.

Listen, Watch, Plug In

Everything Beyond Monogamy lives at beyond-monogamy.com — every episode, the blog, and the FREE livestream every Thursday at 7PM Central. You can also catch us on FullSwapRadio every Thursday at 2PM and 7PM. Lots of events are coming up, so hit the Events tab on the site and watch the socials.

This episode is brought to you by SDC — the largest online community for open-minded adults. Your people, all in one place. Sign up at SDC.com and use code 38236.